Sunday, November 20, 2011

Childish Gambino: Camp Review

So music criticism is a new endeavor for this blog, but like Mr. Glover himself, I'm multi-talented, so let's give it a shot. If you've hung out with me at all in 2011, you've probably been annoyed by me raving about Childish Gambino to anyone who would listen, but the dude is insanely talented, and brings a certain brilliance to his music that, quite frankly, is too good to be missed. If you don't know, Childish Gambino is the rap name used by Donald Glover, who plays Troy on Community, wrote for '30 Rock' during the best years of that show, who was the star of the "Derrick" comedy group (they made the "Bro Rape" video of youtube fame), and who is a successful standup comedian. As he tells it, he typed his name into a "Wu-Tang Name Generator" site while in college, and has used the name Childish Gambino ever since. He's been putting out original music and remixes for several years now, up to this point for free on his site: www.iamdonald.com, while he flirted with various record labels and become more and more of a legitimate musician. Since September '09, he's put out several full-length mix-tapes/albums and an EP, and each one has steadily improved. In Summer 2011, Glover signed with Glassnote records, and "Camp" was released on 11/15/11.

Glover is an impressive and honest lyricist, blending pop-culture references with layered metaphors and personal reflections and the silly with the heartfelt. His verses run the gamut from clowning around to heartfelt questions on race, love and loneliness. It doesn't take very long to realize that this is one very smart, funny, sensitive dude. There are persistent themes: zero to hero, not being "black" enough, being picked on and called "gay" that pop up again and again, and are explored with a nuance, self-awareness and wit that frankly, isn't very common in hip hop. There are a lot of dick jokes and sophomoric humor that he winkingly acknowledges as just having fun. There's a sense of play throughout that offsets the more serious fare. As an artist, he manages to be serious enough to be taken seriously while keeping the whole thing fun. That's what successful comedians do, and that quality is successfully brought to his music as well.

The album has a definite arc to it, starting with the introspective "Outside", and building into more "party" tracks that are "Firefly" and "Bonfire" before offering the almost painful introspective lamentations on love and modern relationships that are "Letter Home" and "Heartbeat". The album closes with a long monologue that's part story about Summer Camp, part explanation for who he is today that has a poignancy and power far beyond a junior high camp story.




It's common to compare Gambino to either Drake or Kanye West, and superficially, that seems fair, although it's not quite apt. Drake is an actor turned rapper who sings his own hooks, and Kanye is a suburban raised kid who produces his own beats. Gambino is much less chained to hip-hop convention - which is a welcome relief. Does he talk about women and partying? Absolutely.. but the entire thing comes with a wink and a certain self-deprecating outsider's take. Where Kanye is blustering faux swagger and cockiness, Gambino is often a painfully self-aware glimpse into something deeper. Drake is the more polished performer, but is also much more grounded in hip-hop convention. It seems to me that Gambino might be delivering on what Kanye seemed to promise back with "College Dropout", that of taking hip-hop outside of the greater culture and bringing it to a more relatable level. I've read more than one review that compared this albumb to "College Dropout", but to me, the Kanye album that it's most similar to is "Graduation", and I think that's simply because of Gambino's experience and relative polish he's gotten while self-producing his music. He emerges not so much as a new artist but as a young artist. Still developing, but mature enough to have a voice. Where "College Dropout" didn't have a cohesive narrative as much as it had some very strong tracks, this one really rewards listening to the album in its entirety.

I can say right now that "Camp" is either my favorite or second favorite album of the year. It and Bon Iver will have to fight it out. I'm extremely excited to see where Childish Gambino goes as an artist - I think it's clear that if he chooses to put his mind to it, he can be a force in hip-hop. If you can't tell from this post in its entirety, I have a serious mancrush on Donald Glover and find his music to be extremely relatable and legitimately great in levels beyond "Hey, the dude from Community is rapping".

Check out this album, you won't regret it. 9/10

Saturday, November 19, 2011

2011: The Year in Film: "J. Edgar" Review

It's fascinating to me how much of what makes up our world is due to historical happenstance, the influence of a particular man (or woman) or set of circumstances that happened to be in a certain place at a certain time. So much of our society and its rules and institutions seems to have been fated or inevitable, when in fact it's the result of a determined person or lucky coincidence that happened to have the foresight or good fortune to rise to an occasion or exploit an opening. One of the individuals who had an outsized impact on American society, our worldview and our institutions over the past century was longtime (we're talking 40+ years) FBI director J. Edgar Hoover. In fact, I'd be prepared to make an argument that he's one of the 10 or so people MOST responsible for shaping what we, as a nation and society are today. So, needless to say, a flick about his life starring one of the best actors working today, in Leonardo DiCaprio by one of the most important directors working, in Clint Eastwood, becomes a must-see.

This film has gotten mixed reviews.. most recognize its achievement while finding the narrative lacking. Most of all, I respect its ambition. I question whether another director could get a project like this green-lit. It's not quite a biopic, not quite a history of the FBI and not quite a historical drama a la say "The King's Speech". What it is, most of all, it seems to me, is a study of who Hoover WAS, why he was important, and what that means to us today. Through the lens of important events in his life and important events in the history of the FBI, we evaluate the rise and fall of an American icon and institution, a strange little man who built a monolith from scratch and whose legacy continues to resonate today. The film is framed as Hoover dictates a book to various FBI agents and outlines the start of his career, focusing on crucial points, like the Lindbergh baby case, the war on crime and the red scares of the early 1920s and the 1950s. The narrative skips from the past to the 1960's, where Hoover as an old man, has private files on every important person in the country and is, some say, the most powerful man in the nation. The narrative is extremely effective at points - doing a great job attempting to explain what made Hoover tick, for example, and fails at others - for instance, the story surrounding Hoover's illegal surveillance in the 1960's is less clear.

A flick like this is dependent entirely on the cast. It takes place in backrooms and offices and without actors capable of carrying the load, would completely collapse under its own weight. DiCaprio is great as J. Edgar. Simply great. He brings the perfect mix of eccentricity, paranoia, confidence and unease to a complicated, strange and yet powerful man. Judi Dench is great as well as Hoover's domineering mother, who had an undue influence on her son for the entirety of her life. Armie Hammer (who played the Winklevii in the Social Network..) is great as Hoover's #2 man, confidant, lifelong companion, probable lover and conscience, Clyde Tolson. Naomi Watts is more than adequate as Hoover's other lifelong companion, his personal secretary and keeper of his files, Helen Gandy. This flick is completely full of "those guys".. as basically every character is a man, and an Eastwood film attracts known actors. (For example - Jeffrey Donovan, the star of "Burn Notice", plays Robert Kennedy)



In showing, rather than telling and preaching, this film puts the right twist on Hoover's outsized legend. Everyone knows he was rumored to wear women's clothing, but this film doesn't focus on his strange personal habits, his modernization of law enforcement or his mistakes, focusing instead on what made the man tick, in an effort to understand what made the FBI what it is today. I appreciate that ambition.. and while that effort wasn't perfectly executed, the effort to document the meteoric rise and degeneration into paranoia of an icon is the sort of effort that just isn't made too often in Hollywood. For that, I applaud everyone involved, as Hoover's is a story that needs telling, particularly in our modern age of an omnipotent Federal government. This man is responsible for Federal Law Enforcement (FBI, DEA, ATF, you name it) as we know it, and his sweeping vision and ambition is responsible in large part for so many things.

Is the film perfect? No. But it is well-acted, often tragic and surprisingly touching in parts, and there's a lot more that works than there is that doesn't. So come for the acting, stay for the commentary on who we are and how we got here. If there's one outsized criticism from me, it's that the lighting in the film is HORRIBLE - it's not black and white, but every scene seems to take place at dusk/twilight, even when the scenes are in the middle of the day. It's rather distracting.

With that being said, this film does a lot more right than it does wrong - and the ambition alone is enough to add a point. 8/10.